9 Mistakes to Avoid When Setting Your New Year’s Resolutions
It’s called the “fresh start effect.” Every January, it often feels like we are given a clean slate to start over. It’s no wonder millions of us take the time to come up with our ambitious New Year’s resolutions.
Unfortunately, even with all that motivation and hope for a better year, most resolutions don’t make it past the first few weeks of the year.
It’s not like we are not committed. I’d argue the beginning of the year is one of the best times to start over. Most New Year’s resolutions fail because of how the goal was set in the first place.
In fact, most resolutions fail long before you’ve even taken the first action. It could be because the plan wasn’t clear, the goal was too big or too vague, or you had 20 goals on your New Year’s resolutions list. And you repeat the same mistakes year after year, expecting different results.
Below, I go into detail about 9 mistakes to avoid when setting your New Year’s resolutions to avoid sabotage. I also show you how to set goals you’ll actually stick to throughout the year.
Get Your 2026 Mini planner
Enter your email below to receive our freebie delivered to your inbox.
Mistakes to Avoid When Setting Your New Year’s Resolutions
1. Setting Too Many Goals at Once
It’s super tempting to use January as a complete reset and try to reinvent every part of your life at once.
For my 2025 New Year’s resolutions, I had a long list of goals, from fitness to finances to routines to mindset to relationships. Unfortunately, I am sad to say that I quit quite early in the year.
The truth is, when you try to pursue too many changes at the same time, you divide your attention and often overwhelm your brain. If you chase too many goals, you’ll spread yourself too thin and eventually quit all those goals.
This year, choose one main resolution. Make sure it is the goal that matters most. The one that would create the biggest impact in your life if you follow through.
For me, this year, my main focus is my finances. I want to become debt-free, build an emergency fund, and actually take saving and investing seriously.
2. Choosing Goals without a System Behind Them
We are all so good at setting up our New Year’s resolutions. “ I want to get healthier.” “ I want to save more.” “ I want to read more.”
All these are so great. But goals alone are not enough. You need systems to make it happen. Think of systems as a plan of action. This plan of action is what will make it easy to see these goals through. Otherwise, you’re just relying on motivation. Which always always fades.
For this year, before settling on your New Year’s resolution, define when you’ll take action, where it fits into your routine, how often it happens, and the exact steps you’ll follow.
And remember, don’t complicate it. The systems should be simple enough to follow through, even on some low-energy days.
If you want extra support on how to build better habits, and by extension better systems, Atomic Habits by James Clear is an awesome resource.
3. Not Tracking Progress
Here’s the truth. If you don’t really track a goal, it becomes easy to lose sight of it. Days will pass, then weeks, and eventually you only remember your resolution when you realize you haven’t thought about it in a while.
So, there’s no question. You have to track your New Year’s resolutions. Tracking is how you stay connected to your progress.
Tracking keeps your goal visible. And it gives you small wins that boost dopamine and keep you motivated.
Without tracking, you won’t notice the small improvements or the fact that you’re slipping.
You can use a simple Google Sheets habit tracker or weekly and monthly check-ins to track your progress.
4. Relying on January Motivation Alone
The beginning of the year feels so inspiring for most of us. This motivation is real and so powerful. It’s often called the “fresh start effect.” It creates a sense of possibility that makes change feel easy.
But alas, it doesn’t last. Once the routine of everyday life returns, the sparks die. So, if your resolution is only built on that “fresh start effect,” it won’t last past February.
When selecting your New Year’s resolution, create a plan that will keep you grounded even when your motivation is nonexistent.
I mean, set weekly goals, decide in advance how you’ll stay consistent in the later months of the year, build real habits around your regular schedule, and most importantly, expect your motivation to dip sometimes and prepare for it.
5. Not Planning for Slip Days
Most of us, with good intentions, of course, set resolutions with the expectation that we will follow through perfectly.
But that is not realistic. Life will happen as it always does. You’ll have busy weeks, stressful days, or some days when you just don’t feel like doing anything. I know, because I have had such days.
The best thing you can do when setting your New Year’s resolutions is to plan for days you don’t show up for yourself.
Because when you expect perfection, even a small slip can feel like a big failure. One missed day becomes two, then a week, and before long, you’ve convinced yourself that you “fell off.”
So, assume slip days will happen, and then plan how you’ll handle them.
You can create a minimum effort version of your goal, a simple reset routine, or a “don’t skip twice” rule.
Just remember, when setbacks are part of the plan, they stop being a reason to quit.
6. Making Your Resolution an All-or-Nothing Plan
The all-or-nothing mentality is the reason so many resolutions fail. If your plan only counts when done perfectly, then you’re definitely gonna quit at the first sign of a slip-up.
Make your New Year’s resolutions a combination of strong days, average days, and days where you just managed the bare minimum.
And even if at the end of the year you’ve only achieved 50 percent of your goal, isn’t that better than zero or 10 percent?
7. Not Having Any Accountability
Trying to rely only on yourself sounds very admirable. I’ll admit I am the kind of person who would lean this way. But unfortunately, I know first-hand that it often leads to quiet quitting.
When no one knows your goals, it becomes easy to ignore them or simply abandon them. After all, no one would know. After all, you haven’t disappointed anyone.
That’s why you need some accountability. And not for pressure, just for support, which can really help your consistency.
Whether you want to improve your health, finances, habits, or routines, having a person or group to check in with can dramatically increase your follow-through.
I plan to share my goals with my sister to help me hopefully stick to my New Year’s resolutions this year.
8. Choosing Vague or Unrealistic Goals
A goal like “get healthier” or “save more” feels inspiring, but will most probably fail. Such goals don’t tell you what to do and when to do them. And when a goal is too vague, the brain doesn’t know where to start and opts to procrastinate instead.
Unrealistic goals have the same problem. They’ll create pressure, and you’ll quickly feel overwhelmed and just quit.
This year, define your resolution into something clear and realistic.
Plan for a specific outcome, break the goal into smaller actions, make sure it fits into your current lifestyle, and begin with a simple step you can commit to immediately.
9. Treating Your Resolution Like a Temporary Challenge Instead of a Lifestyle Shift.
Many of us approach our resolutions as a “challenge.” You know, go hard at it, push yourself to your limits, try to fix everything immediately.
Unfortunately, if the only way you’ll achieve your resolution is through super intense effort, it won’t last very long.
A resolution should become part of your identity.
Get Your 2026 Mini planner
Enter your email below to receive our freebie delivered to your inbox.
Final Thoughts on Mistakes to Avoid When Setting Your New Year’s Resolutions
Statistics show a whopping 80 percent of us quit our New Year’s resolutions by mid-Feb. And the kicker is, we don’t fail because we are not capable or disciplined. We fail because we don’t set out resolutions to fit into our real lives.
So, this year, try to avoid these 9 common mistakes when setting your New Year’s resolutions, and you’ll see just how achievable your goals will be.
Design your goals with long-term success in mind, and don’t give up too quickly; give yourself a chance to follow through throughout the year.
Until the next one, have a great 2026, my loves.
